WISH YOU WERE HERE
PINK FLOYD
1975
Harvest, Columbia/CBS
Prod. by Pink Floyd
Is it strange that I am finding Wish You Were Here to be
Pink Floyd’s most depressing disc? I mean, it’s far less depressing than The
Final Cut, but that is largely because The Final Cut is mostly unlistenable.
But Wish You Were Here evokes sadness different from that of the following
Waters-focused albums. While a juvenile form of the cynicism that envelops
Animals and the first disc of The Wall slithers into the album, it is bookended
by mournful odes; while still personal, they are a more shared experience,
based upon the mental degradation of former Floyd frontman Syd Barrett. While
the album is largely dedicated to his memory, it lives beyond it, and intimate
knowledge of the band’s history should not be necessary to enjoy the simple
elegance of the album.
The dynamics of Pink Floyd are on pure display here. The
music shifts from gorgeous to spacey to aggressive to rollicking time and time
again, and no song is longer or shorter than it probably should be. These
aren’t playlist songs, though; “Shine On You Crazy Diamond,” a gorgeous ballad
with multiple shifts, is split into two fifteen minute parts, and even the
shortest song, the cynical “Have A Cigar,” is over five minutes long. Still,
there’s a dramatic shift between Dark Side of the Moon and Wish You Were Here; Dark
Side of the Moon carried far more jazz in its roots, while Wish You Were Here
is a more rock-focused album.
While the lyrics and songwriting credits shift largely from
guitarist David Gilmour to bassist Roger Waters, Wish You Were Here is home to
most of Gilmour’s best guitar work. While Dark Side of the Moon has already
come and gone, and though “Comfortably Numb” looms on the horizon, none of his
work places quite as much emphasis on beauty as Wish You Were Here. Both “Shine
On You Crazy Diamond” and “Wish You Were Here” carry long sections where
Gilmour’s guitar is given first chair, and it is the most melodic and sustained
in his career. His acoustic guitar playing receives a limelight almost
throughout, the only exception being “Have A Cigar,” perhaps the most open and
brazen torching of the music industry Pink Floyd has ever put out, with
rollicking guitar lines throughout.
Sadly, the musical anarchy of these critiques is facile in
comparison to Dark Side of the Moon’s “Money,” and both “Welcome to the
Machine” and “Have A Cigar” simply feel out of place between the more personal
dedications of the bookends. Waters isn’t a master of this cynicism yet, and
the digs at the industry almost feel token. They are definitely musically
interesting, though; “Welcome to the Machine,” in particular, has a lot of
great acoustic guitar work, the sort that The Wall uses on “Is There Anybody
Out There?” to great effect. And keyboardist/synthesizer wizard Richard Wright
goes into hysterics throughout, proving his efficacy to the band with “Machine”
and “Diamond” time and time again. But “Machine” and “Have A Cigar” are too
broad and impersonal to be more than musically interesting; “Machine” would
have fit better on Meddle or Side Two of The Wall, while “Have A Cigar” is the
sort of boogie that could have divided “Goodbye Blue Skies” and “Empty Spaces”
moderately well.
The larger narrative of Wish You Were Here is confused; the
critiques of the music industry simply feel out of place next to the beautiful
ballads bookending the album, and a longer middle section might have made the
album feel a little more complete. The critiques seem to echo a sort of regret
or envy for the type of music Barrett would have liked to keep making, a
sensation that Pink Floyd had “sold out.” However, this bitterness is still too
distant to truly be affecting; on Wish You Were Here, all one needs to follow
is the mourning this group of friends feels towards the loss of the one who
brought them all together. Or simply play audience to a group of extremely
talented musicians playing the most simplistic and beautiful soundscapes they’ve
accomplished thus far.
4/5
HIGHLIGHTS: “Shine
On You Crazy Diamond (Parts I-V)”, “Wish You Were Here”, “Shine On You Crazy
Diamond (Parts VI-IX)”
MISSED OPPORTUNITIES:
“Welcome to the Machine,” “Have A Cigar”
CATALOG CHOICE: The
Wall (Note: For those looking to
understand what kind of musical mind Barrett was, check out Piper At The Gates
of Dawn)
NEXT STOP: Yes,
“Close To The Edge”
AFTER THAT: The
Who, “Tommy”
No comments:
Post a Comment